How to Distinguish Japanese ‘Wagyu’ Beef at Grocery Stores and Restautrants – Kobe Beef is Not Everything

In Japan, popular meat are chicken, pork and beef. Occasionally, duck, mutton and veal are served. In specific areas, sometimes the meat of wild boar, horse, goat, bear, rabbit and venison are consumed. Among them, beef, especially Japanese ‘Wagyu’ is considered as one of the most luxury food.

Reflecting its worldwide popularity, Wagyu is getting attention as one of the strategic export items and even some countries are trying to produce their own Wagyu. According to the Japan Agricultural News, a number of Wagyu brands are registered and being applied in the United States where the crossbred cattle between Japanese breed and Angus can be sold as Wagyu as well.

Also in Japan, how to distinguish beef labelling is quite complicated. Beef distributed in Japan can be roughly classified into three: Wagyu, Kokusan-gyu (domestic beef) and imported beef. It’s a bit tricky that Wagyu and domestic beef (Kokusan-gyu) are not the same.

beef distributed in Japan

Wagyu:

Japanese beef ‘Wagyu’ consists of four breeds: Japanese Black (Kuroge Washu), Japanese Brown (Akage Washu), Japanese Polled (Mukaku Washu), and Japanese Shorthorn (Nihon Tankaku Washu).  The breeds are strictly controlled. Among them, the most popular one is Kuroge Washu, which beef is densely marbled.

Kokusan-gyu:

It literally means ‘domestic beef’ but in fact, ‘domestic beef except Wagyu.’ Kokusan-gyu consists of Holstein and crossbred cattle. It is less expensive than Wagyu.

Japanese beef products have identification numbers to enable their traceability except for some processed products.


So what’s Kobe beef?

Kobe beef  has become a byword for Japanese luxury beef. In fact, it is one of the major three Kuroge Wagyu brands. The others are Matsuzaka beef and Omi beef (or Yonezawa beef).

According to the research by Japan Meat Information Service Center in 2008, 155 Kuroge Wagyu brands are recognized.

Indeed, they are all the same breed. The brands are normally named after the place where the cattle have been grown, not the place they were born. In many cases, the breeders and growers are different.

There is no doubt the major brands promise the quality, but it doesn’t mean that other brands are inferior. Each brand has an elaborate and unique technique producing Wagyu. As long as it’s labeled ‘Kuroge Wagyu’ or ‘Kuroge Washu’ in Japan, they meet the standard for the highest quality beef,  so it’s rather a matter of preference which brand you choose.


Grading, Cuts or Recipe? 

Meat Grading has been used by professional buyers or cooks to choose beef.  If you’re interested to learn the details,  check out the website of American Wagyu Association which offers clear explanation.

As consumers, it is more important to choose the best recipe for Wagyu and select the suitable cuts (e.g. sirloin or fillet for the steak). The popular recipes for Wagyu are Teppan-yaki, Steak, Sukiyaki, Shabu-shabu, and Yakiniku (grilled like Korean barbecue).

Personally I don’t like too much fat, so I’m not attracted by A5 Wagyu sirloin steak which will give me heartburn. For steak, I would rather prefer lean, grass-fed imported beef.

Historically speaking, the marbled beef had been developed for ‘Gyu Nabe (Beef Pot)’, which is the ancestor of eastern style ‘Sukiyaki’ of today. To make this, beef needs to be boild for a while, so the marbled beef is the most suitable as it will remain soft after boiling. When served as Sukiyaki, the beef is sliced extremely thin, and just a couple of slices will give us a lot of safisfaction. I love this modest way of enjoying Wagyu the most among many Japanese recipes.

DSC03057

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s